Mattresses are built to support an average person’s weight; for sleepers over 230 pounds, however, a firm bed that resists compression and rutting while offering adequate pressure relief should be considered a suitable option with an extended warranty and that fits their sleeping position.
Back sleepers weighing more than 230 lbs require exceptional support to reduce hip and shoulder discomfort and ensure spine alignment. An innerspring mattress or hybrid with high-density foam would be a suitable option for these heavy sleepers.
1. Loom & Leaf
The Loom & Leaf Mattress is made with eco-friendly and safe materials that make it an excellent choice for anyone who prioritizes environmental sustainability. From its GOTS-certified organic cotton and wool cover to its natural flame retardant barrier, this mattress was manufactured with the environment in mind. Plus, its soft euro-style pillowtop and multiple layers of memory and poly foam create deeper sinkage to contour around your body’s contours, relieving pressure while conforming perfectly to each unique body shape.
Memory foam mattress of this caliber usually don’t come equipped with cooling gel layers to promote airflow through and prevent overheating; while other hybrid and innerspring models might sleep cooler than memory foam variants, this Loom & Leaf model excels at maintaining temperature balance and keeping sleep temperatures comfortable.
Like other memory foam mattresses, the Loom & Leaf does not offer great edge support – which could pose problems for combination or side sleepers who regularly move to the edge. Furthermore, its lack of responsiveness or bounce may pose issues for some sleepers.
While the Loom & Leaf mattress features a distinctive sink-in feel, its dense foam base and transitional layer help maintain its structure and support heavier people without sinking too deeply into it. Ideal for back sleepers of all sizes with moderately heavy frames; providing adequate spinal alignment to eliminate shoulder and hip pain.
The Loom & Leaf mattress excels in isolating motion, making it a fantastic option for couples sharing a bed. Even in its firmer model, our accelerometer tests showed minimal motion transfer when compared with other mattresses we tested; this was especially important for heavier individuals who might otherwise be disturbed by their partner tossing and turning or getting up during the night for bathroom trips. Furthermore, Loom & Leaf sells an adjustable frame which pairs seamlessly with their mattress, making finding a suitable arrangement simple for you and your partner!
2. Zenhaven
Saatva’s Zenhaven mattress is an all-natural latex model featuring eco-conscious materials. They prioritize using components certified as GREENGUARD Gold or Rainforest Alliance certified so as to eliminate harmful chemicals during its construction, plus it is both hypoallergenic and odor-free, making it suitable for those with sensitive skin or allergies.
This mattress boasts a dual-sided design with two distinct firmness levels: Luxury Plush offers a medium soft feel and is recommended for most sleep positions, falling around 5/10 on our firmness scale; Gentle Firm can offer more support, which may suit back or stomach sleepers looking for firmer surfaces.
This mattress boasts two latex cores on both sides for foundational support and weight distribution, as well as latex comfort foam to add soft, springy bounce. A quilted cover made of organic cotton and wool increases breathability and acts as a non-chemical fire retardant.
According to its manufacturer, this mattress is suitable for most sleeping styles and body sizes, including back sleepers under 230 pounds who want a soft-to-medium feel. If you have a heavier frame however, this mattress may feel too soft for you and may not provide sufficient spinal alignment.
Zenhaven mattresses come with a generous 365-night trial period and free shipping, so if they are not ideal, minus a $99 transportation fee, they may be returned for a refund and donated to shelters or charity organizations in good condition.
The Zenhaven mattress is an excellent natural latex alternative to memory foam and provides no synthetic chemicals or odor. Furthermore, natural latex has an initial break-in period, typically up to 30 days, during which it fully settles – however, due to this potential discomfort some initial discomfort may arise; that’s why the Zenhaven comes equipped with a trial period so you can decide if this mattress fits for you or not.
3. Avocado Green
Avocado Green is an organic latex hybrid mattress with a medium firmness rating, ideal for back sleepers while supporting average-weight side sleepers as well.
This mattress’s first layer of GOLS-certified organic Dunlop latex offers luxurious softness while the second layer of pocketed coils provides zoned lumbar support – this keeps its natural “S” curve without exacerbating back pain issues overnight. Furthermore, our spine alignment testing resulted in this mattress receiving a perfect score, making this an excellent option for those experiencing back issues.
Heavier stomach sleepers may struggle to find sufficient support with this mattress due to its soft surface; hip elevation may not be achieved fully. Heavier stomach sleepers might benefit more from trying firmer alternatives like the Brooklyn Bedding Titan Plus Luxe hybrid mattress.
Lightweight side sleepers should find this mattress an excellent choice, with its 2 inches of extra height from its pillow top cradling shoulders, hips and thighs comfortably. Plus, its organic fabric with naturally-hydrated silica helps regulate temperature more effectively.
However, this mattress lacks adequate edge support and may be unsuitable for couples or seniors with mobility concerns. Furthermore, its nonresponsive surface means heavier individuals may experience some motion transfer when sharing a bed.
As with many bed-in-a-box mattresses, this mattress comes packaged in a box and may take some time to expand and settle into its new surroundings. As with most such beds, however, there may also be an initial period of off-gassing as it adjusts itself and adjusts itself over time.
The Avocado Green mattress can be purchased online and delivered straight to your door free of charge, offering a 365-night trial period and 25-year warranty. Residents in NYC may visit one of their showrooms where you can test out this mattress before making their decision; financing options may also be available for it.
4. Brooklyn Bedding Titan Plus
The Brooklyn Bedding Titan Plus mattress is a hybrid bed featuring layers of quality foams atop heavy-duty coils, designed for durability and support for sleepers over 230 pounds. Its solid construction and firm feel make it suitable for back, side, or stomach sleepers – as well as couples sharing one mattress. There are two varieties of this hybrid mattress available–a regular hybrid Titan model as well as the more costly Plus Luxe version.
The Titan Plus features a luxurious fabric cover quilted with one inch of gel memory foam and a cooling panel constructed of phase-change material, and comes equipped with an inch of TitanFlex foam designed to ease pressure off of the body before transitional polyfoam cushions to conform to body contours and provide extra cushioning. It’s finished off by a thick layer of support foam for stability and reduced sinkage as well as transitional polyfoam cushioning which offers cushioning while conforming to body shapes.
This durable mattress performed exceptionally in both our lab tests and at home, making it one of the top mattresses available online for heavy individuals. Unfortunately, however, its main drawback was not providing as much edge support than some other models do.
Its medium firmness makes this mattress suitable for back, side and stomach sleepers; however, light sleepers may find it too firm. Firmness should not be confused with support – which refers to how effectively a mattress keeps your spine neutral.
If you are uncertain of which mattress would best meet your needs, Brooklyn Bedding provides a 120-night trial and 10-year warranty – read up on these policies by visiting their website.
This mattress can be used on foundations with minimal to no flex, such as box springs, platform beds, adjustable frames and slatted bed frames. Brooklyn Bedding designs foundations specifically tailored for their mattresses; however existing foundations can also be used instead; their website provides an interactive tool enabling users to select their foundation type and find suitable mattresses to match it.
The Sleep Loft - Online mattress showroom 